|"Um, I dunno..."|
But this is a different column. Sort of. I don't have a solid opinion, at least, not yet. So I'll pose these questions:
- If the Yankees lose the AL East -- a likely scenario as of today -- but qualify for the Wild Card, was it a good season?
- If the Yankees stumble and only manage to win the second Wild Card, was it a good season?
- If the Yankees go on the road and lose the Wild Card game and spend one day in the post-season in the last 3 years, does Brian Cashman get credit for getting the Yankees back to October?
- Or did he fail to upgrade a mediocre team at the deadline and watch his team fade down the stretch?
As for that opinion of mine, I'm decidedly torn.
On the one hand, the Yankees, on paper, weren't expected to contend this year. The fact that they have played themselves into contention is remarkable. As a bonus, young players that represent the future of the organization -- Betances, Bird, Severino -- have been able to contribute and excel. Even if the Yanks make a quick exit from the playoffs, they will have laid a solid foundation for 2016.
Or have they? The 2015 Yankees' offense has been led primarily by Alex Rodriguez, a 40-year old DH, and Mark Teixeira, a 35-year old who hasn't played a full season in 5 years. A-Rod is currently in a slump and Teixeira won't be back on the field for another two weeks. It's unlikely that either A-Rod or Teixeira can turn back time on another season. Who, in 2016, is going to provide that power? Will Greg Bird or Aaron Judge? How much does Brian McCann or Carlos Beltran have left?
Only time will tell...