Showing posts with label NCAA. Show all posts
Showing posts with label NCAA. Show all posts

Friday, December 20, 2024

The Old Man and the Heels

Bill Belichick holds a North Carolina sweatshirt with #38 on it
A Hall of Fame coach, once revered, is struggling. He is 73 years old, trying to adapt to modern football amidst whispers that the game has passed him by. Finally, once it has become clear that the situation has reached its nadir, the coach and the team part ways.

That's what happened to Mack Brown at North Carolina. But that story is eerily similar to how Bill Belichick left New England. So when rumors started flying that Belichick was interested in taking over the head coaching job at North Carolina, I was immediately skeptical. After all, what sense did that make? Swap one over-the-hill coach for another? 

Yet here we are: Bill Belichick, with zero head-coaching experience at the college level, has signed on to lead North Carolina. Serving as head coach of a power conference program in the NIL-Transfer Portal Era is hard work. Just ask Nick Saban, the GOAT himself, how he felt about doing that job in his 70s. The job is so complex these days, that two head coaches - Chip Kelly and Gus Malzahn - both left their head-coaching jobs to become assistants instead.

There are some coaches who have found success at both the NCAA and NFL levels. Notable examples are Pete Carroll and Jim Harbaugh. But both had extensive experience in the college and pro ranks before becoming champions. (It's also worth noting that upon winning a National Championship last year at Michigan, Harbaugh bolted right back to the NFL.)

But back to Belichick. What, exactly, does he offer North Carolina RIGHT NOW? Belichick's Patriots went 29-38 over his last 4 seasons, losing in their only playoff appearance. Clearly, the NFL was no longer enamored with him. Next year's top high school recruits would have been 11 years old the last time Belichick won a Super Bowl. How much pull do you think a man not known for his charisma will have in those living rooms? Many coaches complain that with the portal, recruiting has become a year-round job, on top of all the other responsibilities a head coach shoulders. How much appetite do you think a 72-year-old man will have for that recruiting trail? 

One saving grace might be that North Carolina is not Alabama. A new coach who wins 9 games and flirts with a playoff appearance is a lost season in Tuscaloosa. In Chapel Hill, that's considered winning. But North Carolina administrators, fans and boosters are expecting a lot from their $50 million investment. What happens when the Tar Heels don't immediately succeed? Belichick's prickly personality and adversarial relationship with the media are well known. In his Super Bowl days, that could have been considered charming. Winning covers a multitude of sins. Terse answers and a curmudgeonly vibe don't go over as well when you're 6-6.

I don't have high hopes for the Belichick Experiment at North Carolina. Upon being introduced, Belichick spoke about how he wants to create a "pro program" at Carolina. "I would say through my experience, what we did in terms of training, developing players, running pro systems, pro techniques." Except the Tar Heel players are not pros. They are 19- and 20-year old kids, prone to head-scratching decisions and behavior. There are just too many ways for a coach to fail, even before he ever takes the field. Recruiting players, both in high school and via the portal, then constructing a coaching staff around those players. In a world of infinite possibilities, the genius of Bill Belichick just might translate into a college football powerhouse. My guess is that the number-crunchers at North Carolina will eventually need to figure out how much of Belichick's contract they're willing to eat before starting over, yet again.

Saturday, December 18, 2010

Legends and Leaders and Buckeyes, oh my!

The Big Ten came up with names for the newly-minted, 12-team, two-division football league that will begin play next season. No big deal you say? Ordinarily I'd agree. Except for the choice of names: "Legends" and "Leaders". Really.

So some team next season will be the "Big 10 Leaders leader"? We already know that there aren't any highly-ranked officials in the Big 10 that can count, so why should their grasp of language be any better? Predictably, it didn't take long for public outcry to begin building against these ill-advised names. Suprisingly, though, is how quickly the Big 10 brass, specifically Big Ten Commissioner Jim Delany, has reacted to the bad reviews:

"I think we have enough experience with names, and expansion and development of divisions, to know that you never, rarely, get 90 percent approval rating. But to get a 90 percent non-approval rating was, you know, really surprising."


If Michigan had a guy who could backpedal that fast, they wouldn't have the nation's 111th-ranked pass defense. The most remarkable result of the backlash is that Delany is already talking about changing the names. That's just short of convening a committee.

I agree that by randomly shuffling the teams to create the divisions it makes it difficult to use geographical designations. I also don't think Delany is wrong in thinking that Wisconsin wouldn't want to compete in the "Hayes" or "Paterno" division.

That said, the men who run the Big 10 are all highly-paid executives at major institutions. Someone go grab some English Lit majors, put them in a room and check back in a few hours. You'll have some new division names in no time.